Interviews
The interviews serve to show their values and opinions of
the participants and how they change as they experience the life of a refugee.
For example, when the participants are introduced, we get a clear sense of
their values from the beginning. As viewers, we are therefore able to measure
how the characters’ perspective change or stay the same. In the opening
interviews, Raye says that she thought it served the ‘bastards right’ who were
affected by the ship that crash off Christmas Island and Roderick says that he
fears being seen as a ‘huge lefty’. Raquel tells us that she is a ‘bit racists’
and that she doesn’t like ‘Africans’ and Darren says that people who come by
boat illegally should be ‘immediately expatriated’. Gleny thinks Australia has
the ‘capacity’ to take ‘more refugees’ and Adam says that we are ‘spending
millions of dollars housing ‘these’ criminals’. With the exception of Gleny,
almost all participants are prejudiced against refugees.
As the episodes progress, the participants become more aware
of the plight of refugees. In Episode 1, After Maisara’s story Raquel reflects
that she is not sure how she would cope being in the country the Masudi family
come from and experiencing something like Maisara did. She has empathy as she
feels that seeing something like what Maisara described would be distressing.
When Adam comes out of the detention centre, he says that he experienced a
‘reality check’ as he spoke to people who are experiencing a hopeless situation.
He talks about one man who has had his application denied several times and
said he would commit suicide rather than return to Iraq. The man tells him that
rioting is not far off at the detention centre. There is another shot of the
moon in the distance. This shows that his attitude that the refugees deserve
the harsh treatment they receive has shifted to a more compassionate
perspective.
The footage of the Villawood Immigration Detention Centre
gives the insight into the tortured state of many of the people who live there.
The narrator tells us that Wasmi visits here and he wants the group to visit
his friends. The narrator tells us that in the last 9 months 3 detainees have
committed suicide and 18 have self-harmed themselves. The group reflects on
their experiences speaking to the detainees. They are all affected by the
experience. Gleny says that she felt the hopelessness of one of the person she
spoke to and Adam experiences a ‘reality check’.
Activity
- Analyse how the interviews represent ideas about discovery. An example has been completed for you.
Modelled response
In Episode 2, as the male participants work in the fields
with the refugees, they are shocked by the harsh conditions they refugees work
under. Adam asks how much the men get paid, to which he is told that the
workers are volunteers. This confuses Adam. In exchange, they get food and
shelter. They don’t look for work outside, as they are afraid of getting
arrested. As Adam hoes the ground, his anger at their predicament rises. He
empathises with them, comparing men at home who have a ‘pay check to go home
to’ and these men who ‘have nothing’. The medium shot of him with his head to
the ground, not looking at the camera shows that he is deeply affected by the
injustice.
No comments:
Post a Comment